⚠️ 讨论类 vs 观点类:别搞混了!
很多同学容易把 Discuss Both Views 和 01 Agree or Disagree(观点类) 搞混。两者的核心区别在于视角不同:
🎯 三种立场选择
在动笔之前,你需要决定自己的立场。讨论类作文允许以下三种表态方式:
无论选择哪种立场,有一点非常重要:两个主体段都要写得充实。不能因为你支持A,就把B写得很敷衍——考官要看的是你能否公正地呈现双方观点。
📝 6.5分稳健模板
开头段 Introduction
People have different views about whether [改写题目].
In this essay, I will discuss both sides and explain why I [agree with one side / partly support both].
这个开头直接明了:
- 🎯 交代话题
- 📋 预告结构(会讨论双方)
- 💡 暗示自己的立场
主体段一:观点A
On the one hand, some people believe that [观点一].
This is because [解释].
For example, [例子].
As a result, [总结影响].
主体段二:观点B
On the other hand, others argue that [观点二].
In many cases, [解释].
For instance, [例子].
Therefore, [总结理由].
| 连接词 | 作用 |
|---|---|
| On the one hand... On the other hand... | 标准的双边对比结构 |
| some people... others... | 引出不同群体的观点 |
| This is because... / In many cases... | 解释原因 |
| As a result / Therefore | 总结该观点的逻辑 |
结尾段 Conclusion
In conclusion, although both sides have their own merits, I believe that [重申你的立场].
It is important to [提出建议或预测结果].
🚀 7分进阶模板
开头段 Introduction
The issue of whether [改写题目] has sparked ongoing debate.
While some individuals believe that [观点一简述], others argue that [观点二简述].
In my view, I tend to agree that [你的立场].
主体段一:观点A
On the one hand, many people support the idea that [观点一].
This belief is often based on [解释原因].
For instance, [具体例子或场景说明].
As a result, it is understandable why this side argues that [总结观点一的核心逻辑].
主体段二:观点B
On the other hand, others maintain that [观点二].
One major reason is that [解释].
A good example would be [例子].
From this perspective, [总结这方观点的合理性].
| 6.5分表达 | 7分表达 |
|---|---|
| others argue that... | others maintain that... |
| For example... | A good example would be... |
| Therefore... | From this perspective... |
结尾段 Conclusion
In conclusion, although both perspectives have their merits, I firmly believe that [重申你的观点].
Balancing both sides is essential, but [你的立场提供的优势/建议] makes it a more convincing approach in the long run.
✍️ 实战范文对照
📗 6.5分范文
📊 简评:结构完整,两边都讨论到了,结尾也有明确立场(支持optional)。但语言偏简单,缺乏对深层原因的挖掘。
📘 7分范文
📊 简评:语言更精炼,分析更深入。注意主体段二中的 "intrinsic motivation“(内在动机)和 ”checkbox task"(打勾式任务)这类表达,展现了对问题的深度理解。
⚠️ 讨论类写作的常见误区
🔗 相关学习资源
🔄 题型对比(必看!):
- 06 观点类 vs. 讨论类的区别 - 这两个最容易混淆
- 01 Agree or Disagree(观点类) - 观点类完整模板
📊 其他题型:
- 03 Advantage & Disadvantage(利弊类) - 利弊分析类
- 04 Cause & Effect(原因影响类) - 原因影响类
- 05 Problem & Solution(问题解决类) - 问题解决类
🎓 综合练习:
- 07 从同一话题看五大题型的区别 - 一个话题五种写法
📚 素材积累:
- 九大话题万能观点库 - 各类话题的现成论据